Editors’ Picks: Our 10 Favorite Bourbons

By Darcy Lenz
September 01, 2015
Credit: Photo: Jennifer Causey
The best bourbon bottles for mixing and straight sipping.
Start Slideshow

1 of 11

Bourbon Barrel Breakdown

Credit: Photo: Jennifer Causey

To some, bourbon is the foundation for favorite concoctions; for others there's no way to take it but straight. The beauty of the spirit is that every way is the right way, provided you have the right bottle. Depending on the mixer, a cocktail bourbon needs to be either mild or so distinct it defines a drink's personality. If the only place that seems appropriate to add a splash is the bottom of an empty rocks glass, you have a winner for a great solo sipper.

Advertisement
Advertisement

2 of 11

1. Mixer: Evan Williams Black Label

Credit: Photo: Jennifer Causey

86 proof, $12

A standard flavor profile that won't outshine other elements in a drink, EV Black is great for cocktails where a fair bit of mixer is involved.

3 of 11

2. Sipper: Old Grand Dad

Credit: Photo: Jennifer Causey

80 proof, $20

At the lower end of the proof spectrum, OGD offers impressive sweet-sour fruitiness balanced by a heady spice edge. Keeping an on-the-rocks-friendly budget bourbon on hand is a good call; with notable complexities and vanilla sweetness, this is ours.

Advertisement

4 of 11

3. Mixer: Four Roses Yellow

Credit: Photo: Jennifer Causey

80 proof, $20

It's gentle, it's graceful, and even if you're out of mixer, keep pouring—it's so very drinkable all by its lonesome.

5 of 11

4. Sipper: Redemption

Credit: Photo: Jennifer Causey

82 proof, $25

Lip-smacking buttery flavor and a silky-smooth swallow distinguish this exceptional bourbon. The sleek bottle boasts a great price, making it a stellar pick for gifting. 

6 of 11

5. Mixer: Wild Turkey 101

Credit: Photo: Jennifer Causey

101 proof, $25

The 101 is delicate for a high-proof bourbon but still rich in flavor. Faint citrus aromas balance deep notes of caramel. A splash gives backbone to complex cocktails involving aromatics and bitters.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

7 of 11

6. Sipper: Bulleit

Credit: Photo: Jennifer Causey

90 proof, $35

Rich caramel notes and a warm spiced finish with hints of nutmeg make Bulleit a crowd-pleasing favorite.

8 of 11

7. Mixer: Maker's Mark 46

Credit: Photo: Jennifer Causey

94 proof, $35

A versatile darling of the mixing category, the 46 is a solid match for both minimalist bevs and more involved concoctions. With full body and vanilla flavor, it's best savored in bourbon-forward drinks.

9 of 11

8. Sipper: Woodford Reserve

Credit: Photo: Jennifer Causey

90 proof, $37

Well-rounded butterscotch with midproof bite feels both rugged and indulgent. This approachable spirit welcomes you warmly with open arms.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

10 of 11

9. Mixer: Orphan Barrel Forged Oak

Credit: Photo: Jennifer Causey

90.5 proof, $65

Mixing may seem like a misstep given the price tag, but this is a bourbon that brings a massive wow factor to simple cocktail classics. With robust smoky-peaty qualities, Forged Oak will take you to the peak of your Old-Fashioned game.

11 of 11

10. Sipper: Russell's Reserve Single Barrel

Credit: Photo: Jennifer Causey

110 proof, $50

This is the whiskey burn you want: a spicy punch at the front, quickly dissipating to a velvety-smooth finish, with no lingering harsh flames. Most definitely a spirit you'll want to cozy up with as fall creeps in.

Replay gallery

Share the Gallery

Up Next

By Darcy Lenz