12 Delicious Exotic Mushrooms

By Ann Taylor Pittman
October 23, 2014
Credit: Photo: Justin Walker
Beyond the buttons and the portobellos lies a world of amazing textures and flavors. 
Start Slideshow

1 of 18

More Mushrooms, Please!

Credit: Photo: Justin Walker

A brilliant speciality food store can excite a cook's mind like nothing else, whether the shop curates salt, cheese, chocolate, or, in the case of San Francisco's Far West Fungi shop in the Ferry Building, mushrooms. Our adventure was inspired by an almost surreal mushroom assortment, ranging from lacy and delicate to ponderously dense, from bright orange to fawn brown to black.

What could we do but order a variety box for our Test Kitchen? Soon the package of woodland treasures arrived. More than a dozen exotic varieties saturated the kitchen with aromas of wood and loam.

The recipes here offer a taste of the fun we had—days of recipe research and development. 

Advertisement
Advertisement

2 of 18

Black Trumpet

Credit: Photo: Justin Walker

Texture: Delicate, with a bit of chew; cooks down to a soft texture

Taste: Bright and nutty, faintly eucalyptus-piney

Recipe ideas: Sauté and combine with firmer vegetables or scrambled eggs, or toss into pasta or risotto.

3 of 18

Sautéed Black Trumpets with Asparagus and Lemon

Credit: Photo: Justin Walker

This is as simple—and delicious—as it gets: earthy mushrooms, crisp asparagus, and a wee hit of citrus to bring it all together. Because it's both robust and delicate, this side would go with pretty much any entrée.

'Shroom subs: Chanterelle, morel, reconstituted dried wood ear mushrooms

Advertisement

4 of 18

King Trumpet

Credit: Photo: Justin Walker

Texture: Scallop-like

Taste: Sweet and meaty, buttery, between steak and scallop

Recipe ideas: Sauté, stir-fry, pickle.

5 of 18

Lion's Mane

Credit: Photo: Justin Walker

Texture: Spongy, sweetbread-like, absorbent

Taste: Concentrated chicken glacé or roast chicken skin flavor with a hint of crabmeat, intensely meaty, faintly livery

Recipe ideas: Roast with butter; sauté.

6 of 18

Roasted Lion's Mane Mushrooms with Sherried Shallots

Credit: Photo: Justin Walker
View Recipe: Roasted Lion's Mane Mushrooms with Sherried Shallots

Lion's mane mushrooms are an amazing discovery—incredibly meaty, with a faint, almost livery nuance—so this dish plays off the classic liver-and-onions combo with sweet and tangy shallots. Serve as a light entrée with a fall salad and crusty bread, or as a hearty side dish with robust meats such as lamb or beef.

'Shroom subs: Shiitake, cremini

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

7 of 18

Oyster

Credit: Photo: Justin Walker

Texture: Velvety

Taste: Delicate and sweet

8 of 18

Chanterelle

Credit: Photo: Justin Walker

Texture: Chewy, slick

Taste: Musty, haylike, hazelnut sweetness

Recipe ideas: Golden color is lovely in sautés, stir-fries, or pickles.

9 of 18

Pickled Wild Mushrooms

Credit: Photo: Justin Walker

These garlicky numbers are mouthwatering by themselves, and they can also take a salad, cheese board, or burger to another dimension. You can substitute most any mushroom; just trim them accordingly. The earthy pickles taste great after one day, but if you can wait three or more days, they get even better. Store in the refrigerator for up to one month.

'Shroom subs: Pretty much any mushroom will work here; just trim or slice to fit the jar.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

10 of 18

Morel

Credit: Photo: Justin Walker

Texture: Delicate and sponge-like with hollow caps

Taste: Deeply earthy-nutty

11 of 18

Blue Foot

Credit: Photo: Justin Walker

Texture: Meaty and firm

Taste: Bright and strongly earthy

12 of 18

Maitake

Credit: Photo: Justin Walker

Texture: Chewy, snappy, springy

Taste: Roasted dark-meat chicken, nutty essence

Recipe ideas: Sauté and toss in potpie, pasta, risotto, or tacos.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

13 of 18

Mai-Tacos

Credit: Photo: Justin Walker

The recipe title here is a playful pun, taking its cues from the pronunciation of the star ingredient. Mushrooms and chiles play surprisingly well together, and this peppy concoction highlights the maitake's robust, roast chicken–like flavor.

'Shroom subs: Oyster, pioppini, portobello, shiitake, chanterelle

14 of 18

Nameko

Credit: Photo: Justin Walker

Texture: Springy, slightly crunchy, sticky gelatinous coating

Taste: Slightly fruity, foresty-earthy

Recipe ideas: Applications where the sticky coating aids in thickening, such as soups or sauces for pasta

15 of 18

Lobster

Credit: Photo: Justin Walker

Texture: Firm, like an artichoke heart

Taste: Sweet hints of seafood

Recipe ideas: Versatile, great to toss into soups, sautés, or roasted dishes

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

16 of 18

Nameko and Lobster Mushroom Soup

Credit: Photo: Justin Walker

This brothy soup was a home run at taste testing. Mushrooms and bacon have always been good friends, and here the nameko's sticky film gives depth and body to the smoky broth (which is inspired by Momofuku chef David Chang's bacon dashi). You can make the broth in advance; it will keep in the refrigerator for several days.

'Shroom subs: For the nameko: enoki, pioppini (though broth will have less body). For the lobster: maitake, fried chicken, shiitake

17 of 18

Pioppini

Credit: Photo: Justin Walker

Texture: Firm

Taste: Peppery, intense

18 of 18

Shiitake

Credit: Photo: Justin Walker

Texture: Chewy

Taste: Rich, bold, meaty

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Replay gallery

Share the Gallery

Up Next

By Ann Taylor Pittman