We’ve been so obsessed with alternative nut butters lately (can you blame us?) that good old-fashioned peanut butter has been politely pushed to the back burner. But leave it to Jif to remind us of our first love—creamy, unbelievably smooth, and now seasonally spiced peanut butter.

Jif’s Limited-Edition Whipped Peanut Butter & Pumpkin Pie Spice is light and fluffy with hints of pumpkin and cinnamon—a fun family-friendly treat for this time of year. With no partially hydrogenated oils and only 140 calories per serving (50 calories less than Jif’s traditional peanut butter), you get all the peanut butter flavor without any of the guilt. Spread it onto toast or graham crackers, or use it as a dip for pretzels and apple slices.