Meet the Milk Substitutes

There's an amazing list of choices these days. Here's how they fared—sipped and cooked.

Milk Subsitute Varieties
Photo: Photo: Randy Mayor

ALMOND MILK

Taste & Texture: Nutty and toasty with a faint bitter background. Ground almonds are mixed with water, filtered, then fortified with nutrients and thickened with agents like lecithin and carrageenan for body.

Cooking: Resulted in quick bread with the best rise. But the almond flavor overwhelmed our pudding.

60 calories per cup; 0g sat fat, 1g protein

RICE MILK

Taste & Texture: Tastes exactly like sweet rice. Gets what little body it has from a small amount of safflower or canola oil.

Cooking: Our pudding was thinner and sweeter than that made with dairy. Rice milk was too watery for bread—it turned out gummy.

120 calories per cup; 0g sat fat, 1g protein

HEMP MILK

Taste & Texture: Chalky with a strong, fermented vitamin-like flavor. Even in brands that use thickeners, hemp milk—yes, made from seeds of the hemp plant—is likely to be cloudy with particles.

Cooking: Unwelcome flavor permeated the quick bread and pudding, where texture suffered (ours looked curdled).

100 calories per cup; 0.5g sat fat, 3g protein

COCONUT MILK

Taste & Texture: Similar to canned light coconut milk, but the smooth dairy-case kind has less sweet coconutty flavor and body, despite thickeners and as much sat fat as whole cow's milk.

Cooking: Imparted little flavor to either recipe. Like rice milk, it produced thin pudding and gummy bread.

80 calories per cup; 5g sat fat, 1g protein

SOY MILK

Taste & Texture: Most soy milks have thickeners to get that rich, milk-like consistency—the benchmark for dairy subs. Mildly nutty and creamy with a vegetal note.

Cooking: Browning was deep and even in the bread; the pudding turned out too thick.

80 calories per cup; 0g sat fat, 6g--8g protein

How We Tested: To learn how these milk subs cooked, we tested them in chocolate pudding and blueberry quick bread.

    1 of 1

    Most Popular

    1. Our Best Easter Desserts

      Find the perfect ending to your Easter feast with these light and fresh springtime desserts.
    2. Easy, Gorgeous Easter Feast
    3. Easter Menus
    4. 100 Easy Chicken Recipes
    5. Cooking with Quinoa: 25 Recipes