Recipe Makeovers

Lighter, healthier, but just as tasty: See how we made over these favorite dishes.

Recipe Makeover: Carrot Cake

We radically slim down one of the most egregiously over-the-top cakes in the universe. By Sidney Fry, MS, RD

Carrot Cake Recipe

Warm spices and brown sugar add rich, caramelized flavors to this carrot cake.

John Autry

Click to Enlarge

  • Build a Better Cake

    A successful cake finds perfect balance among these four essential ingredients.

  • Carrot Cake Recipe Makeover Flour

    1. Flour

    Flour contributes body, structure, and texture to the framework of a cake. Weigh thte flour and measure it carefully; this is essential to lower-fat baking.

  • Carrot Cake Recipe Makeover Sugar

    2. Sugar

    Sugar add volume, tenderness, and texture to the batter. Granulated and brown sugars team up to provide a level of sweetness that rounds out the warm spices.

  • Carrot Cake Recipe Makeover Butter

    3. Butter

    Real butter lends a softer texture, firm crumb, and melt-in-your-mouth goodness. Soften butter to a range of 65º to 70º for maximum leavening.

  • Carrot Cake Recipe Makeover Eggs

    4. Eggs

    Eggs bind ingredients, provide structure, and aerate the cake. To incorporate more air, beat the eggs ater each addition, resulting in a great rise.

View Recipe: Carrot Cake

Some time back, carrot cake became the poster child for a healthy-sounding food that is actually a fat and calorie disaster. But we'd forgotten how much of a disaster it could be until we looked at an online recipe from a celebrity chef who shall go unnamed. There it was, in all its splendor, weighing in at 1,460 calories and 28 grams of saturated fat in one gargantuan three-layer slice. 

Few are the recipes that have been made over quite this dramatically. We shaved about 1,000  calories and 89 grams of total fat. Yet, it's delicious: Creamy butter and smooth buttermilk create a perfectly moist, tender texture. Earthy brown sugar brings out the warm cinnamon spices. Real-deal cream cheese and butter maximize frosting flavor. Low-fat fromage blanc and a light sprinkle of toasted pecans make it a special, vastly lighter treat.

1,460 calories per slice
99 grams total fat
28 grams saturated fat
24 tablespoons of oil for moisture
Frosted with one stick of butter and a pound of cream cheese
Pecan extravaganza

284 calories per slice
9.7 grams total fat
4.9 grams saturated fat
6 tablespoons butter and a rich splash of buttermilk
Frosted with a hint of butter, cream cheese, and fromage blanc
A perfectly toasted sprinkle

View Recipe: Carrot Cake

See More: Low-Calorie Desserts

Page 1

More Ways To Get Cooking Light



JavaScript must be enabled to use this Calendar module.

Our Best Easter Desserts

Find the perfect ending to your Easter feast with these light and fresh springtime desserts.

Black and White Angel Food Cake Recipe