Fish Substitutions
 
What to use when the variety you need isn't available

Fish divide easily into three categories: delicate-, medium-, and firm-fleshed. These categories reflect how fish respond to cooking methods and which substitutions work.

R: Recipe Calls For
S: You Can S
ubstitue

Delicate
Treat delicate fish with care when you cook them; they flake easily and have a soft texture when cooked. These fish are traditionally sold as fillets, and they are best prepared by poaching, braising, pan-frying, or baking.

R: sole / flounder
S: turbot, plaice, fluke, all varieties of sole/flounder

R: cod
S: orange roughy (mild)

Medium
These fish flake easily, but with more resistance than delicate fish, and are firmer when cooked. They are the most versatile fish to cook and can be used when your recipe specifies "or other flaky white fish."They are best prepared by baking, broiling, braising, pan-frying, or grilling.

R: arctic char
S: steelhead trout, salmon

R: mahimahi
S: grouper, monkfish

R: red snapper
S: halibut, walleye (sweet, delicate), all varieties of snapper

R: tilapia
S: bass (fresh water), pike, tilefish

Firm
These fish don't flake easily when cooked and have a meaty texture. They are best prepared over high heat -- by grilling or sautéing, for example.

R: pompano
S: amberjack, catfish

R: tuna
S: swordfish, trigger fish (mildly sweet)

 

Copyright 2008 Cooking Light magazine. All rights reserved. Privacy Policy