Downarrow-small-lineGroupStaff FaveGroupClose IconEmailLike Cooking Light on FacebookShapeFollow Cooking Light on InstagramMenu IconPrintSearch IconSpeech BubbleFollow Cooking Light on SnapchatFollow Cooking Light on TwitterWatch Cooking Light on YouTubeWatch Cooking Light on Youtube

Taste Test: Store-Bought Pie Crusts

Cooking Light staff sampled 12 nationally available frozen and rolled-dough piecrusts in four blind tastings.
Image Credit: Photo: Randy Mayor

ABOUT TRANS FAT: Most ready-made crusts contain trace amounts of trans fat. Not ideal, but we tested three trans-fat free crusts and felt they did not meet our taste standards. You can make your own trans-fat-free crust, with our Homemade Pie Crust recipe.

FROZEN CRUSTS: WINNER: Marie Callender’s Deep Dish Pie Shells, $3.15 (2 [9-inch] crusts per pack)
Superbuttery with a slight saltiness. Layers so crispy they could almost be peeled. Testing note: Frozen crusts perform best when blind-baked, then filled.

REFRIGERATED CRUSTS WINNER: Pillsbury Refrigerated Pie Crusts, $2.46 (2 [9-inch] crusts per box) 
By far the flakiest of all the crusts we tested. Pillsbury’s toasted, buttery flavor and golden color were on par with homemade.

REFRIGERATED CRUSTS RUNNER-UP: Great Value Rolled Dough Pie Crusts $2.36 (2 [9-inch] crusts per box) 
Its neutral flavor puts focus on the filling. Straight out of the box, its thickness is ideal for heavy custards or quiches.